Diane Ravitch Talks School Reform, the Chicago Strike, and the
http://prospect.org/article/diane-ravitch-talks-school-reform-chicago-strike-and-testing-vampire
Read the entire piece. http://prospect.org/article/diane-ravitch-talks-school-reform-chicago-strike-and-testing-vampire
http://prospect.org/article/diane-ravitch-talks-school-reform-chicago-strike-and-testing-vampire
Diane Ravitch.
Do you think there is a crisis in American
education?
No. I think the crisis in American education is
that there is a concerted effort to destroy it. That is a crisis—that’s a
genuine crisis. Is there a crisis of academic achievement? No.
First of all, the test scores are the highest
they’ve ever been in history on the National
Assessment of Educational Progress, which is a no-stakes test. The
scores of white kids, black kids, Hispanic kids, and Asian kids are the highest
ever in history. What you hear from Bill Gates and [former chancellor of
Washington, D.C., public schools] Michelle Rhee and all the others is
we’re in a period of decline, all the schools are obsolete, the test scores are
flat. Nonsense. They have been going up steadily for 40 years and they are the
highest they’ve been in history.
Number two, the graduation rates today are the
highest in history. Number three, the dropout rates are the lowest in history.
Is there a crisis in American education? Yes: We
have all these Wall Street-funded foundation people running around saying we
have to get rid of public education and saying all these phony things about our
schools.
But it's not just Wall Street, right? Both
Democrats and Republicans have advocated more testing and more charter schools
as key methods of improving public schools. In fact, education seems like one
of the few areas where political party isn't a useful indicator of a
politician's position. How do you see the political landscape for public
schools?
The agenda of reform today is actually the
traditional Republican agenda. The Republicans have been saying now since
probably the 1960s that what’s needed is testing, accountability, choice, and
competition. That is the conventional, traditional GOP agenda.
Democrats have said since the 1960s that what’s
needed is resources, equality of opportunity, and equity. The Democratic agenda
got lost. The Democrats are now embracing a Republican agenda. So when you say
that there’s not a partisan divide, it’s because Obama and Duncan have embraced
the GOP agenda. The GOP agenda is exactly the same as it was 40 years ago.
No comments:
Post a Comment