However, they missed the boat on how to get to improved civic
education.
While it is accurate that we have a general problem of
civic engagement of the young, it is also true that we have a very
specific problem with the rate of Latino and Asian voter participation
and civic engagement. Together
they comprise over 60% of the students in our schools. And, the textbooks have yet to acknowledge
their presence.
Rates of voting and voter registration provide a
window into civic engagement. The proportion of state voter
registration that is Latino and Asian has remained far below the proportions
of these groups in the state’s overall population. In 2010, Latinos in the
state made up 37.6% of the general population while they were on 21.2 % of the
registered voters. The Asian population was 13.1 % of the state but only
8.1 % of the registered voters.
Children and young adults need to see themselves in the curriculum.
Students, particularly students of color, have low levels of attachment to
California and U.S. civics messages in significant part because the
government institution they encounter the most- the schools- ignore the
students own history, cultures and experiences.
A fundamental way to engage students in civic culture is to
engage them in their own schools and communities. That is where the
students most encounter civic opportunities.
The 1987 California History Social Science Framework
still in use today to guide the selection of California textbooks
expanded African American, Native American, and women’s history
coverage but remains totally inadequate in the coverage of Latinos and Asians.
The only significant change between the 1985 and the 2005 adopted Framework was
the addition of a new cover, a cover letter, and a photo of Cesar Chavez.
When the 51% % of students who are Latino , and the 9
% who are Asian do not see themselves as part of history, for
many their sense of self is marginalized. Marginalization
negatively impacts their connections with school and their success at
school. It contributes to an up to 50% drop out rate for
Latinos and some Asian students. A more accurate, more complete
history would provide some students with a a sense
of self, of direction, of purpose, even a sense that they
should stay in school and learn more. History and social
science classes should help young people acquire and learn to
use the civics skills, knowledge, and attitudes that will prepare them to
be competent and responsible citizens throughout their lives.
Add their
stories to the history textbooks, add their literature to the literature
textbooks. They are not migrants from some distant place. They are California's
children. Include them.
And, yes,
a revised civics course and appropriate support for teacher in-service
preparation is needed. The place to do
that is in the History/ Social Science framework scheduled to be revised in
2015/2016. It will require focused attention
of many, including scholars, political leaders and editorial boards to overcome
the inertia of the past frameworks.
A more accurate, more complete history provided in
Ethnic studies courses would provide some students with a a
sense of self, of direction, of purpose, even a sense that
they should stay in school and learn more. And, ethnic studies would
provide Anglo students with an informed, accurate history of the
political and cultural development of the state. Ethnic studies classes should
help young people acquire and learn to use the civics skills, knowledge,
and attitudes that will prepare them to be competent and responsible citizens
throughout their lives.
The Department of Education and the Board of Education can
start by revising the California History/ Social Science Framework to include
the history of the majority of students in the schools and by joining LA Unified in requiring
Ethnic Studies Classes in high school.
There is a network of scholars and professionals interested in
writing a more complete history of our state. This has been said before
and we will keep reminding these folks.
Duane Campbell,
Democracy and Education Institute.
Sacramento
Readers: Please like
this post on Facebook and forward it to your lists.
We encourage discussion of these issues. Please use the
comments section of this blog.